Old Chapel Cemetery
This cemetery is located .4 mile north of the flashing light in Fly Creek, it is located at intersection of Hoke Street and County Route 26.These lists are a composite of burial records and tombstone inscriptions. Many stones and missing and lost since the cemetery was first started in the late 1790s. Inscriptions read by Florence Michaels and Marjorie Willsey in 1973; research by Harriet Rogers Typed by Marion Brophy
ALDEN, Juliann, daughter of William and Sara, Died Sept.30, 1828 in her 16th year
ALLEN, Ezra, Died July 14, 1861 Age 61
ALLEN, Lydia, wife of Ezra W Died March 8, 1882, Age 73
ALLEN, Ruth Leontine, daughter of Ezra W. and Lydia Died Sept. 16, 1861, Age 24
ALLEN, Steven, Died Feb. 27, 181(5?) Age (61)
ALLEN, Lydia, wife of Stephen Died May 12, 1864, Age 78 years, 11 months
ANDERSON Lemuel Died Feb. 16, 1815 Age 80
ANDERSON, Rachel, wife of Lemuel, Died June 9, 1860, Age 92 years, 11 days
AYRES, Phyann, wife of Wm. Ayres, Died Sept.7, 1848 Aged 27 years
BABBITT, Elkannah Died Feb.9, 1807 in his 70th year
BABBITT, Rachael, consort of Elkannah Died Feb. 9, 1815 in her 78th year
BABBITT, Sarah, wife of Warren Died Jan. 2, 1861
BABBITT, Warren, Died July 4, 1847, Age 73 years, 14 days
BADGER, Major John, Died Nov.16, 1833 in the 60th year of his age
BADGER, Orestes, Died Oct 1850, Aged 58
BADGER, Naomi H., daughter of Orestes and Polly Badger, Died Feb.28, 1836
BADGER, Polly VANDERCOOK. wife of Orestes Died July 9, 1861 62 years
BAILEY, Charles Died Sept.8, 1826 in the 75th year of his age
BAILEY,Sarah wife of Charles Died Sept 13, 1826 in the 71st year of her age
BAILEY, John, Died Feb.15, 1858 aged 74 years, 3 months, 7 days
BAILEY, Mary, wife of Roger Died May 26, 1872 71 years, 10 mo., 20 days
BAILEY, Roger Died Feb.1, 1863, 75 years, 2 months, 12 days
BALDWIN, Abner, Died Dec.2, 1834, Age 78 years, 28 days, was in Revolution
BALDWIN,John, Died Jan. 27, 1862, Age 72 years, 9 months
BALDWIN, Julia, wife of John Died May 5, 1878, 90 years, 2 months, 15 days
BALDWIN George William, Died April 7, 1857, Age 31 years
BALDWIN,Everett, son of L.W. and Amanda, Died Sept.27, 1872, age 22 days
BALL Elizabeth, Died Oct.18, 1825, 89 years
BASSETT, Eunice, daughter of Samuel and Ann Bassett, Died May 11, 1856, age 26 years
BEACH, David R Died Dec.13, 1872, age 51 years
BEACH, Minerva, wife of David Died March 5, 1834, 37 years
BOZWORTH, Samuel C Died June 2, 1842 in his 40th year
BROCKWAY, Hannah, wife of Levi Brockway Died Oct.9, 1825, Age 49 years
BROOKS, Diana W., wife of Asa Brooks, Died Aug.9, 1825, Age 30 years
BROOKS, Abel, son of Cornelius and Hannah Brooks Died March 31, 1877, Aged 87 years
BROOKS, Orra, wife of Abel, daughter of John and Martha COLTON Died Dec.7, 1846 Aged 63 years
BROWNELL, Electa Ann, daughter of John & Eliza WILLIAMS, adopted daughter of R.& M. Brownell, Died Dec. 19, 1855, Age 12 years, 1 mo, 1 d
BROWNELL, Mary Ann, wife of Russel Brownell, Died Nov.20, 1853, Age 48 years, 3 mos., 23 days
CAMP, Henry, Died May 30, 1861 Age 50 years
CAMP, Nancy PACKER, his wife Died Nov.30, 1894, Age 79
CHENEY, Ebenezer, Died Sept. 2, 1800 60 years Nearby marker, Corp l Ebenezer Cheney, Wyll s Ct., Mil. Rev. War.
CHENEY, Prissilla, wife of Ebenezer, Died Feb. 26, 1813, 72 years
CHENEY, Ebenezer, Jr. Died March 10, 1803 34 years
CLARK, Harma, wife of John Clark, Died Feb.1, 1860, Age 68 years, 3 months, 20 days
CLARK,Hannah, Died Jan.1, 1851 Age 50 years
CLARK, Peter, Died Dec.30, 1838 Age 69 years, 2 months
CLARK, Ruth, wife of Peter Clark, Died May 25, 1843 Age 38 years 6 months
CLARK, John, Died March 28, 1873 Age 82 years
CLINTON, John, 1752-1832, Soldier of Fifth N.Y. 1779 Willet s Levies. 1781 Revolutionary War
CLINTON, Mary, wife of John Clinton, Died Dec. 16, 1805, in her 57th year
COLEMAN, Dr. Noah, Died 1801 (uncle of Robert J. Roberts)
COLTIS, Elizabeth A., Died Dec. 16, 1851
COOK, Mary, Died Oct. 30, 1860 Age 47 years
CROSBY, John G. Died March 28, 1850 Age 75 years
CROSBY, Joseph, Died May 31, 1888 82 years
DENNIS, Almira G wife of Oliver H. Dennis Died Jan. 16, 1840 in the 27th year of her age
DEWEY, Martha, Died Oct.23, 1834 Age 26 years
DEWEY, Robert, Died Jan. 12, 1839 in the 33rd year of his age
DEWEY, Truman Died May 26, 1851 Age 80 years 9 months
DEWEY, Abigal, wife of Truman Died May 19, 1836
DRAKE, Chandler, Died Jan.9, 1826 in his 20th year
EISLE, Anna, wife of Henry Eisle, Died Aug.6, 1831 Age 69 years
FELLOW, Mercy, wife of Alexander, Died 1840, Age 58
FISKE, Anna, wife of Henry Fiske, Died Aug.5, 1854 Age 69 years
FOWLER Lucinda, wife of S.W. Fowler Died Dec.7, 1842 Aged 45 years
GALLUP, Celinda, wife of Raymond Gallup, Died Aug.31, 1851 Age 66 years
GALLUP, Deana W., daughter of D.D. and S.M. Gallup Died March 18, 1842, Age 1 y, 1 m, 15 d
GALLUP, Eliza A., wife of Loyd G. Gallup Died Sept.6, 1850 Age 38 years, 9 mo.
GALPIN, Andrew Silas Died Nov.21, 1825 Age 4 months
GOFF, Aurelia, wife of James Goff and daughter of Levi BROCKWAY Died Feb.8, 1821, Age 21 years
GREASY, Joseph Died May 31, 1888 Age 82 years
HALL, John, Died Dec.8, 1861
HECOX, Alexander, Died Feb. 23, 1838, Age 38 years
HECOX, Albert, son of Daniel & Amy Died March 6, 1852, 2 yrs,7 mo 19 da
HECOX, Edwin, son of Daniel & Amy, Died Feb.21, 1850. 5 years, 7 mo
HECOX, Elizabeth, wife of Dr. Samuel Hecox, Died Sept.3, 1852 Age 84 years, 3 months
HECOX, Dr, Samuel, Died March 6, 1846 Age 96 years .
HENRY, Adam, Died June 16, 1838 in the 98th years of his age
HENRY, Elizabeth, Died Oct.16, 1838 in the 70th year of her life
HENRY, Mary, Died May 14, 1845 Aged 72 years
HERRINGTON, Susan Almira, wife of William Herrington. Died Oct.31, 1870, Age 34 years
HIGBY, John, Died Feb.18, 1815 , buried elsewhere
HIGBY, Sarah Died April, 12, 1812
HIGBY, William, Died Nov.29, 1805
HODGE, Elizabeth, wife of Spencer Hodge, Died Sept. 21, 1846, Aged 31 years, 4 months
HOOKER, Amorett L. Died Sept.5, 1815 Age 1 year, 2 months
HOOKER, Emory L Died March 9, 1838 Age 1 year, 2 months - children of Horace and Sophia Hooker
HUBBELL, Jabez, Died Oct.1, 1836 Aged 78 years
JOHNSON, Anna, wife of James Johnson. Died Sept.5, 1867 Age 70 years
JOHNSON, James L Died April 10, 1846 Age 57 years
JOHNSON, Erastus, Son of James and Anna Died Sept.7, 1837 Age 22 yrs,3 mo,
JOHNSON, Edward,,, Died Sept.5, 1835 Age 22 yrs 3 mo
JOHNSON, Parley, Died 4, 1817
JOHNSON, Clarissa, wife of Parley Johnson, Died July 26, 1835 Age 50 years
JOHNSON, Clarence H., son of A.G. and L.E.. Johnson 2 years 6 months
JOHNSON, George Died June 18, 1857 Age 44 years, 5 months, 24 days
JOHNSON, Mary Ann, wife of William NORTHRUP, former wife of George Johnson, Died Oct.19, 1874 Age 59 years 6 months 4 days
JOHNSON, George Died May 28, 1838 Age 85 years
JOHNSON, Chloe, wife of George Died Jan 4, 1830 Age 82 years
JOHNSON, Tabitha, wife of George Johnson Died May 21, 1814 in her 53d year
JOHNSON, William Died June 9, 1834 in his 48th year
JOHNSON, Hannah, wife of William Died May 1, 1843 Age 54 Years 3 months
JOHNSON, Harriete, wife of Col. William P. Johnson Died Dec.5, 1840 in her 24th year
JONES, Samuel M Died March 22, 1844 Age 66 years
KENYON, Olive Died Feb.17, 1838 Age 10 years
KIBBETT, Electa wife of Thomas Died Jan.28, 1848 Age 57 years
KIBBY, Abilene, wife of Jacob Died Jan.15, 1861 Age 93 years 6 months
KING, Susan M wife of Constantine Died Aug.29, 1861 in 95th year
KING, Mary A TORRY, wife of Addison King Nov.1, 1827 - Feb.2, 1894
LANDERS, J. Landers Died Oct.9, 1816
LANGLEY, Edward, Died Nov.19, 1836 Age 29 years
LANGLEY, Elizabeth Died Jan. 31, 1831 Age 29 years
LEROW, Luella Medora, daughter of Alexander and Margaret. Died July 31, 1851, Age 3 years 8 months
LEROW, Mercy, wife of Alexander Died Nov.14, 1845
LIPPITT, Nancy, wife of Loudon Died Feb. 22, 1826 in her 66th year
LITTLE, William Died April 8, 1797 Age 42 years To whose memory this stone is erected by his surviving Consort Mrs. Keziah Little
LUMLEY, Lydia Died May 14, 1902 Age 83 years
MARVIN, Abraham Died May 1, 1825 Age 38 years
MARVIN, Mary, wife of Abraham Died Nov. 13, 1838 in her 54th year
MARVIN, Daniel, Born May 18, 1789 Died July 3, 1856
MARVIN, Orson, son of Daniel Marvin Died Nov. 11, 1818 Age 1 yr 9 mos. 11 d
MARVIN, Daniel, Jr., son of Daniel and Sarah Died July 10, 1826 Age 15 yr 7 mo
MARVIN, Sarah RUSSELL wife of Daniel Died Nov.2, 1867 Age 74 years
MARVIN, David Died Feb. Feb. 17, 1855 Age 83 years
MARVIN,Sabrina G., 1st wife of David Died April 25, 1824 Age 48 years
MARVIN, Sarah, daughter of David and Sabrina Died July 27, 1798 Age 1 yr 9 mo
MARVIN, Sons of David and Sabrina, age 5 weeks and 1 day, died 1808 and 1809
MARVIN, Eleanor, 2d wife of David Died Oct.6, 1848 Age 76 years
MARVIN, Minerva, wife of Theodore Died March 19, 1852 Age 23 years
MARVIN, Diane Died July 3, 1856
MARVIN, John Died Jan. 22, 1845 Age 41 years
MARVIN, Jane, wife of John Died May 24, 1833, Age 32 years
MARVIN, John R Died June 22, 1873
MARVIN, Hannah Jane, dau. of John and Hannah Died May 9, 1884
MARVIN, Henry Edward, son of John and Hannah Died May 15, 18--
MARVIN,Mary Frances, dau of John & Nancy Died July 23, 181? 7 mo 5 da
MARVIN, Sally Ann Born .April 27, 1823 Died Oct. 23, 1886?
MARVIN, William Died May 12, 1819 Age 24 years
MATTESON, Wanton G Died Aug. 24, 1876 Age 50 years
McKINNEY, David,. son of James & Catherine McKinney Died Sept.11, 1827 16 yrs
MERRILL, John, Died April 28, 1812 Aged 65 years
MILLER, Elizabeth Died 1840
NILES, Gidean Died Jan.14, 1822, Age 54 years
NORTH, Anne H, daughter of Stephen & Matilda North Died Sept. 30, 1835, Aged 4 months
NORTH, Albert & Irene North s son and daughter, Born and Died May 5, 1821
NORTH, Edwin, son of Albert and Irene, Died March 4, 1830, Age 11 months
NORTH, Lucy Lovisa, daughter of Stephen & Patience, Died March 11, 1829, Age 4 weeks
NORTHRUP, James Died Oct. 1, 1859, Age 64 years
NORTHRUP, Mary Ann, wife of William and former wife of George Johnson, Died Oct.19. 1874 Age 59 years 6 months (buried with Johnsons)
PARSHALL, Sabrina, wife of John Parshall Died Aug. 28, 1852
PASHLEY, Eunice, daughter of Samuel and Ann, Died May 11, 1856 Age 26 years
PAUL, Elizabeth Born March 26, 1737. Died Oct.18, 1825 in her 89th year
PEASE, Lovina, wife of Robert Pease Died Dec.11, 1866 Age 56 years
PECK, Cynthia Died May 11, 1810 in her 30th year
PECK,Jacob Died March 1, 1813 Age 40 years
PECK, Mercy, wife of Jacob, Died Feb.15, 1840/1 Age 67 years
PRESTON, Daniel, Died Aug.23, 1849 Age 90 years, 3 months
PRESTON, Daniel, Jr. Born April 22, 1810 Died June 27, 1885
PRESTON, Esther, wife of Daniel Died Nov. 27, 1862
PRESTON, Rufus, Died March 25, 1837 Age years, 2 months
PRESTON, Olive, wife of Rufus, Died July 12, 1830, Age 32 years, 2 months
REXFORD, Annis, wife of Ensign Rexford Died May 10, 1857? Age 88 years
REXFORD, Ensign Died June 7, 1836 73 years
REXFORD, Jared Died Feb. 12, 1852 Age 78 years
REXFORD, Phebe, wife of Jared Died June 6, 1848 Age 76 years
REXFORD, Sylvester Died Sept. 5, 1818 Age 59 years
REXFPRD, Susan, wife of Sylvester Died 12, 1857
ROBERTS, George, Born , Conn., April 16, 1765 Died Sept. 7, 1843
ROBERTS, Alice METCALF, wife of George Roberts, Born at Leb. Ct., Feb.22, 1769, Died Oct. 23, 1824
ROBERTS, Lavina A, Born March 26, 1804 Died June 21, 1890
ROBERTS, Horace Knight Roberts, Born Dec. 21, 1808 Died Sept. 18, 1843
ROBERTS, Sible, Born Feb.7, 1793 Died March 1, 1880
ROBERTS, Henry, Born March 10, 1806 Died July 15, 1878 Buried at Westford
ROBERTS, Oron, Born April 29, 1802 Died Oct. 13, 1861 Buried at Westford
ROBERTS, Alice, Born June 13, 1791 Died March 14, 1853 Buried :Lakewood Cem
ROBERTS, Sophia, Born Oct.17, 1794 Died Aug.27, 1857 Buried Floyd, Iowa
ROBERTS, Sally Born July 9, 1797 Died July 18, 1831 Buried Vienna, NY
ROBERTS, George W Born May 6, 1800 Died June 11, 1887
ROCKWELL, John Died July 19, 1827 70 years
ROCKWELL, Betty, wife of John Died Aug. 12, 1821 in her 61 year
ROCKWELL, Charlotte, dau of John and Betty Died Oct.21, 1820 in her 12th year
ROCKWELL, Betsey, Died April 12, 1875 Age 80 years
ROCKWELL, Eliza, Died 1823 in her 23rd year
RUSSELL, Gideon, Died Nov.3,1859 Age 70 years
RUSSELL, Catherine, Died March 19, 1855 in her 33d year
RUTTENBER, William, Died Nov. 20, 1850, Age 87 years
RUTTENBER, Kezia, wife of William Died May 10, 1834, 40/42 years
RUTTENBER, Dorothy Maria, dau of William Died April 1840 Age 35 years
RUTTENBER, Dorothy, wife of William Died Jan.10, 1835, 61 years
SABIN, Hannah, wife of Deacon Timothy Sabin Died Jan.31, 1810 50 years
SCOTT, Alice, mother of Samuel Born 1790 Died 1846
SCOTT, Cylon, Died Aug.17, 1838, child of Samuel and Alice Scott
SCOTT, John P Born Jan.17, 1843 Died March 18, 1843, son of S & A Scott
SCPTT, Leila Born June 22, 1853 Died May 18, 1854, child of S & A Scott
SCOTT, Luzerne Born March 8, 1855 Died Oct.9, 1865
SNELL, Mary, dau of Menzo & Jenett Snell Died Sept.18, 1861 Age 4 years
SPRAGUE, Abiah Died 1796
SPRAGUE, Captain Joseph, Born R.I 1738 Died Otsego March 14, 1809
SPRAGUE, Phyllis, wife of Capt. John, Died July 10, 1814 Age 70 years
SPRAGUE, Mary, dau. of Joseph & Mary Sprague Died. Oct, 28, 1815 5 years
SPRAGUE, Rachael Ann, dau of Joseph & Mary, Died June 27, 1819 12 years
SPRAGUE, Sarah Died March 8, 1797 Age 1 year, 8 months and 20 days
STEERE, Betsy, Died Oct. 21, 1838
STEWART, Lydia, wife of David Stewart Died Sept.6, 1845 Age 52 years
STEWART, Lovina D dau of David and Lydia Stewart Died 1813
TANNER, Mary Ann, dau of Peabody & Roxanna Tanner, Died Oct.10, 1839, Age 7 years, 5 months and 3 d
THOMPSON, Clarissa, wife of John H. Thompson Died Feb.11, 1848 Age 46 years
THOMPSON, nn Eliza, dau. of John H. & Clarissa Thompson, Died Feb.5, 1840, Age 3 years
TOBEY, Lucy, wife of Noah Tobey Died June 9, 1835 Age 23 years, 3 mo, 3 d
TODD, Benjamin, Died Aug.9, 1814, 27 years
TUTTL,E Chester 1828 - 1900
TUTTLE, Eva, wife of John Tuttle 1806 - 1867
VROMAN, Harry April 12, 1895 - Aug.29, 1915
WADE, Daughter of Asahel and Elizabeth Wade, Died Oct. 1817
WALDBY, Sarah, wife of William Waldby, Sr., Died Aug.14, 1829 Age 59
WALDBY, William, Died May 23, 1829 Age 12 years
WALDBY, William, Sr., Died Dec.22, 1825
WELCH, Abigail L Died Sept.16, 1815 Age 31 years
WENTWORTH, Elisha Died Nov.20, 1848 Age 48 years
WENTWORTH, Lucy BROCKWAY, wife of Elisha Wentworth Died Novc.30, 1882 Age 72 years, 9 months & 29 days
WHIPPLE, Eliza, Died Dec.25, 1825
WILLIAMS, Eliphalet, Died June 7, 1817 in his 45th year
WILLIAMS,Mary Russell, dau of Eliphalet and Susanna Williams Died March 21, 1841 Age 25
WILLIAMS, Electa Ann dau of John & Eliza Williams, adopted dau of R.& M . Brownell, Died Dec.19, 1855, Age 12 years, 1 month, 1 day
WILLIAMS, Eliza Ann, wife of John B.Williams Died March 11, 1844 Age 19 years
WILLIAMS, Celestia A. July 11, 1857 - May 16, 1861
WILLIAMS, Leverett B Oct.13, 1851 - Nov.2, 1851
WILLIAMS, Silas, Died Feb.26, 1852 in 82d year
WILLIAMS, Keziah, wife of Silas Died Nov.8, 1857
WILLIAMS, Harley, 1824 - 1827
WILLIAMS, Mary, wife of William Williams Died Dec.15, 1861 in her 86th year
WILLIAMS, Mary M., dau of William and Mary, Died Aug.21, 1828, Age 6 yrs, 2 mo
WILLIAMS, John Died June 6, 1852
WILLIAMS, Paulina, wife of John C Died Sept.4, 1839
WILLIAMS, Margaret, Died Jan.6, 1870